Where to Find the Best Butter Chicken in Melbourne

Butter chicken is one of Melbourne’s most-loved comfort dishes — creamy, mildly spiced, and rich enough to satisfy any craving. With Melbourne’s booming Indian and Nepalese food scene, you’ll find countless interpretations of this classic: smoky, creamy, tandoor-heavy, tomato-forward, or perfectly buttery and smooth.

If you’re wondering where to go for a truly standout butter chicken, here are Melbourne’s top picks — including well-known favourites, local institutions, and a couple of must-try hidden gems.

Best Butter Chicken Restaurants in Melbourne

### 1. Old Durbar Melbourne – Brunswick, Nunawading, Melbourne CBD

Old Durbar takes the top spot for many butter chicken lovers thanks to its exceptional balance of flavour and consistency. Their version is rich without being overly heavy, with a smooth, velvety gravy that coats every piece of tender chicken. The tandoor preparation adds a subtle smokiness that elevates the dish from simple comfort food to something genuinely memorable.

The restaurant itself has a warm, welcoming vibe, combining Nepalese hospitality with a modern Melbourne dining feel. Regulars praise the portion sizes, the freshness of ingredients, and the authentic depth in every curry.

Why it’s number one: Exceptional creaminess, great spice control, and consistently high satisfaction from locals.

### 2. Balti Curry House – Fitzroy North

Balti Curry House is a long-trusted spot known for flavour-packed North Indian dishes, and their butter chicken is one of the stars of the menu. This version leans slightly more robust — richer, aromatic, and layered with spices while still keeping that classic mild butter-chicken comfort. It’s the kind of curry that pairs perfectly with both naan and rice because the sauce is flavourful but not too thick.

Balti Curry House remains popular because of its homestyle feel and the care put into each dish. The butter chicken here is always served fresh, never oily, and beautifully balanced.

Why it’s number two: A reliable, full-flavoured butter chicken with great aroma and generous portions.

### 3. Kolkata Cricket Club – Fitzroy

Kolkata Cricket Club is one of Melbourne’s modern Indian dining favourites, known for its stylish atmosphere and refined flavours. Their butter chicken is smooth and slightly smoky, using tandoor-grilled chicken that absorbs the sauce perfectly. It’s not too sweet and not too creamy — ideal for people who prefer a lighter version that still tastes luxurious.

Guests love pairing it with their garlic naan or saffron rice for an elevated dining experience.

Why go: For a butter chicken that feels a little elevated and works well for nights out or special dinners.

### 4. Elchi – Melbourne CBD

Located centrally and known for its contemporary Indian cuisine, Elchi serves a beautifully executed butter chicken with rounded flavours, silky texture, and a balanced spice profile. Their version is a little more elegant, plated with finesse and made for diners who appreciate a refined twist on classics.

The restaurant ambience adds to the experience, making this a great option for date nights or group dinners.

Why go: A sophisticated take on butter chicken — creamy but not overwhelming.

### 5. Masti – Fitzroy

Masti offers one of the most approachable, consistently praised butter chickens in the inner north. Their curry has a comforting richness, not too thick and not too sweet, with a sauce that clings beautifully to their tandoori chicken pieces. The vibe at Masti is casual yet trendy, perfect for a relaxed meal with friends.

Their butter chicken is one of the most popular dishes on the menu, and it’s easy to see why — it delivers warmth, flavour, and fantastic texture.

Why go: A well-balanced butter chicken perfect for anyone craving comfort food with a modern touch.

### 6. Aagaman – Port Melbourne

Aagaman blends Indian and Nepalese influences, resulting in a butter chicken that stands out for its clean flavours and mild profile. It’s not a heavy dish here — instead, the focus is on a smooth, buttery sauce that highlights the freshness of the ingredients. Many diners love that Aagaman’s butter chicken doesn’t feel overly rich, making it perfect for those who prefer a lighter curry.

The restaurant itself offers a comfortable, relaxed environment suitable for both families and couples.

Why go: A mild, smooth butter chicken that’s consistently satisfying.

### 7. The Butter Chicken Shop – Altona Meadows

As the name suggests, this spot specialises in butter chicken, and their menu revolves around creative twists and consistently tasty classics. The butter chicken here is bold, creamy, and deeply satisfying — a favourite for takeaway lovers who want something quick, flavourful, and reliable.

Their portions are generous, and the flavour always hits the mark, making it a go-to option for anyone craving an easy, delicious butter chicken night in.

Why go: The most convenient and casual option — ideal for takeaway or quick meals.

### Bonus: Kathmandu Momo House – Epping (Mainly Takeaway)

Kathmandu Momo House isn’t primarily known for butter chicken — it’s best known for momos — but their butter chicken still deserves a mention. For a small eat-in and takeaway-focused shop, they serve a surprisingly rich and flavourful version.

The butter chicken here has a homestyle feel: creamy, satisfying, and perfect for pairing with steamed rice or naan. It’s a great choice for locals who want something comforting and tasty without sitting down at a full-service restaurant.

Why it’s a bonus pick: A simple, hearty butter chicken from a beloved Nepalese takeaway spot.

Final Thoughts

Melbourne’s butter-chicken scene is diverse — from elevated, modern dishes to classic homestyle comfort.

• If you want the best of the best, Old Durbar leads the list.

• For a strong, reliable classic, Balti Curry House is a must-try.

• For modern or refined versions, Kolkata Cricket Club and Elchi shine.

• For comfort and convenience, Masti, Aagaman, and The Butter Chicken Shop deliver every time.

• And if you’re in Epping, don’t skip the cosy, satisfying butter chicken at Kathmandu Momo House.