What Not to Do After You’re Arrested in Indianapolis: Avoid These Costly Mistakes

Being arrested in Indianapolis can be confusing, frightening, and overwhelming—whether it’s for a violent crime arrest, a drug possession charge, or any other criminal accusation. How you react in those first hours and days can make the difference between a manageable legal situation and one that spirals out of control. Knowing what not to do after an arrest is just as important as knowing your rights. This guide explains the biggest mistakes people make after being arrested in Indianapolis and how an experienced Indianapolis criminal defense lawyer can help protect your future.

Understanding the Indianapolis Arrest Process

If you’re arrested in Marion County or the surrounding areas, you’ll likely be taken to the Marion County Jail for booking. During this process, officers will record your personal information, take fingerprints, photographs, and note the charges against you. Your arrest might stem from a warrant, a traffic stop, or a sudden on-scene accusation. Depending on the nature of the offense—whether a violent crime arrest or a drug possession charge—you may be held until your initial court appearance.
For most people, the process is intimidating. Law enforcement officers are trained to ask questions and collect statements. It’s important to remember: your words can be used against you, even before formal charges are filed. That’s why one of the biggest things to avoid after an arrest is talking too much—or talking at all—without an attorney present.

Mistake #1: Talking to Police Without an Attorney

You might think you can “clear things up” by explaining your side of the story. Don’t. Whether you’re facing a misdemeanor drug possession charge or a serious violent crime arrest in Indianapolis, anything you say can be twisted or taken out of context. Investigators are trained to gather information, not to help you.
Even if you believe you’re innocent or the situation is a misunderstanding, stay calm and invoke your right to remain silent. Politely say: “I want to speak to my attorney.” Then stop talking. Every experienced Indianapolis criminal defense lawyer will tell you—people often harm their own case by talking too soon.
Instead of talking:

• Ask to contact your lawyer immediately
  
• Stay polite but firm about your right to remain silent
  
• Avoid making excuses, confessions, or casual remarks
  

Mistake #2: Posting on Social Media

In today’s world, one of the fastest ways to hurt your case is through social media. Whether you’re out on bond or awaiting your first hearing, please resist the urge to post anything about your arrest or the events leading up to it.
Police, prosecutors, and even opposing witnesses can and do monitor social media activity. A joke, a meme, or a frustrated rant can easily become “evidence.” For example, if you were arrested for a drug possession charge and later post about parties or substances, it could be used to question your credibility or intentions.
Avoid:

• Posting about your case, arrest, or any involved parties
  
• Sharing photos or comments that could seem incriminating
  
• Deleting posts after the fact (it can look like tampering)
  The best practice? Stay off social media altogether until your Indianapolis criminal defense lawyer advises otherwise.
  

Mistake #3: Resisting Arrest or Being Confrontational

Even if you believe your arrest is unfair or illegal, don’t resist. In Indianapolis, resisting arrest—even mildly—can lead to new charges that complicate your case. Physical resistance, arguing, or refusing to comply with basic instructions can turn a routine arrest into a violent crime arrest, adding serious charges to your record.
Here’s what to do instead:

• Stay calm and avoid sudden movements
  
• Comply with basic commands without arguing
  
• Avoid physical contact or gestures that could be seen as threatening
  If you believe the arrest was improper, your lawyer can challenge it later in court through motions and evidence—not at the scene.
  

Mistake #4: Failing to Contact a Criminal Defense Lawyer Immediately

Delaying legal representation is one of the most damaging missteps after an arrest. Indianapolis prosecutors move quickly to file charges, and early representation gives your attorney more opportunities to protect your rights, preserve evidence, and potentially reduce or dismiss charges before they escalate.
Whether you’re dealing with a drug possession charge, DUI, or a violent crime arrest, your lawyer can:

• Request early discovery (evidence the prosecution has)
  
• Identify procedural errors in your arrest or search
  
• Negotiate bail and release conditions
  
• Advise you before any statements or hearings
  Contacting an Indianapolis criminal defense lawyer immediately allows for a proactive strategy rather than a reactive one.
  

Mistake #5: Ignoring Court Dates or Bond Conditions

After your release, it’s easy to underestimate the importance of following every court and bond rule to the letter. Missing a court appearance—even for a minor misunderstanding—can result in a bench warrant and additional charges. Similarly, violating bond conditions (such as travel restrictions or no-contact orders) can cause your bond to be revoked.
In Marion County courts, judges expect strict adherence to the rules. Even minor violations are seen as disrespect for the process.
Avoid these errors:

• Failing to update your address with the court
  
• Traveling out of state without permission
  
• Missing court or probation check-ins
  
• Contacting victims or witnesses when prohibited
  Your Indianapolis criminal defense lawyer will help you track your obligations and ensure compliance so you don’t accidentally worsen your situation.
  

Mistake #6: Discussing Your Case with Others

Your friends, coworkers, or even family might mean well—but talking about your case outside of privileged attorney conversations can backfire. Anyone you speak with can be subpoenaed or questioned later. Casual remarks can become misquotes or testimony against you.
This mistake is common in drug possession charge cases, where people try to explain or justify their situation to friends. It’s equally dangerous in violent crime arrest cases, where emotional discussions can be misinterpreted.
Protect yourself by:

• Only discussing your case with your lawyer
  
• Avoiding conversations about details, evidence, or witnesses
  
• Being mindful that jail phone calls are recorded
  

Mistake #7: Trying to Handle It Alone

Some defendants think they can save money or “handle” minor charges without legal help. However, Indiana’s criminal laws are complex, and even minor offenses can have significant long-term consequences, including license suspensions, background check issues, or probation violations.
A skilled Indianapolis criminal defense lawyer is familiar with local court procedures, prosecutors, and judges. That local experience is crucial in Marion, Hamilton, Hancock, and the surrounding counties. Self-representation often leads to avoidable convictions or harsher sentences.

Mistake #8: Hiding Evidence or Lying to Your Lawyer

Your attorney can only defend you effectively if they know the whole story. Hiding evidence, leaving out details, or lying about what happened can destroy your credibility in court and limit your defense options. Lawyers are bound by confidentiality. It’s always safer to be completely honest with your defense attorney, even about facts that make you uncomfortable.
Be transparent about:

• What happened before, during, and after your arrest
  
• Any prior criminal history or pending cases
  
• Who was with you and what they might say
  Your Indianapolis criminal defense lawyer can only protect you if they have all the facts.
  

Mistake #9: Pleading Guilty Too Soon

Many people panic and plead guilty quickly, thinking it will “make the problem go away.” Unfortunately, that’s rarely true. A guilty plea—especially to a felony or violent crime arrest—can have lifelong effects on employment, housing, and your record.
Prosecutors may pressure you with early plea offers, but without reviewing the evidence, you won’t know if the case against you is weak or if your rights were violated. An attorney can examine the police reports, lab results, and witness statements before you make any decision.
In drug possession charge cases, for example, evidence can sometimes be thrown out if the search was unlawful. In violent crime arrest cases, witness credibility and intent are critical—and often subject to challenge.
Never plead guilty until your Indianapolis criminal defense lawyer reviews every detail.

Mistake #10: Forgetting About Long-Term Consequences

An arrest in Indianapolis isn’t just about fines or jail—it can affect every area of your life. Employers, landlords, and licensing boards may see your record. Even a misdemeanor conviction can create long-term problems. A quick decision now could limit your options later.
Working closely with your lawyer ensures that your case strategy accounts for your future, not just your immediate concerns. Whether through pretrial diversion, record expungement, or dismissal, your attorney’s goal is to minimize the lasting damage.

Key Takeaways: What You Should and Shouldn’t Do After an Indianapolis Arrest

Don’t:

• Talk to police without a lawyer present
  
• Post or comment on social media
  
• Resist arrest or argue at the scene
  
• Miss court dates or violate bond conditions
  
• Rely on friends, family, or the internet for legal advice
  
• Plead guilty without consulting your attorney
  Do:
  
• Stay calm and respectful
  
• Ask for your Indianapolis criminal defense lawyer immediately
  
• Follow all court and bond instructions
  
• Keep every document, receipt, or report related to your arrest
  
• Tell your attorney everything honestly
  

Why Local Representation Matters in Indianapolis

Indianapolis has its own legal nuances. The Marion County Superior Court system handles thousands of cases each year, from drug offenses to violent felonies. Local attorneys are familiar with the unique characteristics of each courtroom, including which judges prioritize treatment or diversion, and how local prosecutors typically negotiate.
If you’re facing a violent crime arrest, drug possession charge, or any other criminal accusation in Indianapolis, choosing a lawyer familiar with Marion County procedures can make a significant difference in your outcome. Local knowledge, combined with early involvement, allows your lawyer to build a stronger defense from day one.

Final Thoughts: Protect Your Future After an Arrest in Indianapolis

An arrest is not the end of your story—it’s the beginning of your defense. But your first actions after being taken into custody can either strengthen or weaken your case. By avoiding these common mistakes—talking without counsel, posting online, or ignoring court obligations—you give your lawyer the best chance to protect you.
Whether your case involves a violent crime arrest, a drug possession charge, or another criminal accusation, remember: silence and legal guidance are your best tools. Contacting an experienced Indianapolis criminal defense lawyer right after your arrest ensures your rights are respected, your evidence is preserved, and your future stays within your control.